The fairy is a mysterious blonde girl who first appears in Number 1844: Beware The Student Wizards. She dresses primarily in pink and wears artificial wings (or has real ones which are constantly changing form). She speaks primarily using the syllables "La li lu le lo," a reference to a secret, all-powerful organization in the Metal Gear franchise.
She appears again in following comic strips:
- Number 2423: Fairy Tale where Emily catches her, believing she will be granted a wish. The only comic in which the fairy is shown speaking English.
- In Number 3325: I Want To Pet One with a reindeer, which is named Jangles according to the strip's footnotes.
- Number 3327: Fairyspeak shows Fairy girl running after Pintsize on her reindeer.
- Number 3329: Trophy – Fairy has beaten Pintsize for stealing and let her reindeer run over him. The title refers to Pintsize's top hat, which she took as a trophy.
- 3887: Oh, It's Her shows Fairy and her reindeer hoverboarding past an exasperated Roko Basilisk. Roko followed her to The Secret Bakery in 3888: Master Of His Craft.
- 4063: Extremely Unlikely – Winslow meets Fairy's reindeer.
- 4064: Faye Speaks Fairy I Guess? – Bubbles gets to hold her reindeer.